NO (ignored inputs)COMMENT generated by FORT -f "a:0 b:0 f:2" -r 5 "UN & ~UNC & ~SN" submitted by: Franziska Rapp Input: [ a -> a, a -> b, a -> f(a,a), f(b,b) -> f(a,a), f(?x0,a) -> f(a,b) ] Make it flat: [ a -> a, a -> b, a -> f(a,a), f(b,b) -> f(a,a), f(?x0,a) -> f(a,b) ] Time: 0.000 [s] Make it Complete (R^): [ f(b,a) = f(a,a), f(b,a) = f(?x0_1,a), f(b,a) = f(a,b), f(b,a) = a, f(?x0,b) = f(a,b), f(?x0_1,b) = f(?x0,a), f(b,a) = f(b,b), f(?x0_1,b) = f(b,b), f(?x0_1,b) = f(a,a), b = f(a,a), f(b,a) = f(?x0_2,b), f(b,a) = b, b = f(b,b), f(?x0_1,b) = a, f(?x0_1,b) = f(?x0_3,b), f(?x0_1,b) = b, b = f(?x0_1,a), b = f(a,b), a = b, a = f(a,b), a = f(?x0_1,a), a = f(b,b), a = f(a,a), f(b,b) = f(a,b), f(a,a) = f(a,b), f(?x0_1,a) = f(a,a), f(b,b) = f(?x0_1,a), f(b,b) = f(a,a), f(?x0,a) = f(?x0_1,a), f(?x0,a) = f(a,b) ] Time: 0.022 [s] The number of normal forms that must be checked: 845 Time: 0.158 [s] Now checking all the pairs... Time to check pairs: 0.000 [s] The TRS doesn't have Uniqueness of Normal Forms. Counter Example: f(f(?!cx_2,?!cx_3),b) <->* f(f(?!cx_3,?!cx_3),b) proof: f(f(?!cx_2,?!cx_3),b) ->R^ f(f(?!cx_2,?!cx_3),a) ->R^ f(a,b) ->R^ f(a,a) ->R^ f(?!,a) ->R^ a f(f(?!cx_3,?!cx_3),b) ->R^ f(f(?!cx_3,?!cx_3),a) ->R^ f(a,b) ->R^ f(a,a) ->R^ f(?!,a) ->R^ a Total Time: 0.181 [s] problems/732.trs: Success(not UNC) real 0.20 user 0.20 sys 0.00