NO (ignored inputs)COMMENT generated by FORT "NFP & ~CR" submitted by: Franziska Rapp Input: [ a -> a, a -> b, f(a,a) -> f(b,f(f(a,b),a)) ] Make it flat: [ a -> a, a -> b, !cr_0 -> f(a,b), !cr_1 -> f(!cr_0,a), f(a,a) -> f(b,!cr_1) ] Time: 0.000 [s] Make it Complete (R^): [ f(a,!cr_1) = f(a,a), f(a,a) = !cr_0, f(a,b) = f(b,!cr_1), f(b,a) = f(b,!cr_1), f(!cr_0,b) = f(!cr_0,a), f(!cr_0,b) = !cr_1, f(b,a) = !cr_0, f(a,!cr_1) = f(b,b), f(a,!cr_1) = f(b,a), f(a,!cr_1) = f(a,b), f(a,!cr_1) = f(b,!cr_1), f(a,!cr_1) = !cr_0, f(b,!cr_1) = !cr_0, f(b,b) = f(b,!cr_1), f(a,a) = f(b,b), f(a,a) = f(b,a), f(b,b) = f(b,a), f(a,a) = f(a,b), f(b,a) = f(a,b), f(b,b) = f(a,b), f(b,b) = !cr_0, a = b, !cr_0 = f(a,b), !cr_1 = f(!cr_0,a), f(a,a) = f(b,!cr_1) ] Time: 0.010 [s] CPNF: [ !cr_0 … f(b,f(f(b,b),b)), !cr_1 … f(f(b,b),b), !cr_0 … f(b,b), a … b ] Time: 0.000 [s] The TRS doesn't have Uniqueness of Normal Forms. Counter Example: f(b,f(f(b,b),b)) <->* f(b,b) proof: f(b,f(f(b,b),b)) ->R^ f(b,f(f(a,b),b)) ->R^ f(b,f(f(a,a),b)) ->R^ f(b,f(!cr_0,b)) ->R^ f(b,f(!cr_0,a)) ->R^ f(a,f(!cr_0,a)) ->R^ f(a,!cr_1) ->R^ !cr_0 f(b,b) ->R^ f(a,b) ->R^ f(a,a) ->R^ !cr_0 Total Time: 0.011 [s] problems/735.trs: Success(not UNC) real 0.03 user 0.02 sys 0.02