YES ignored inputs: (COMMENT Example 5.5 of [ Ayala-Lincon et al. , LSFA 2015 ] ) NRS: [ (0): |- (not <(and <[]P,[]Q>)>) -> (or <(not []P),(not []Q)>), (1): b#Q |- (not <(forall [a][]Q)>) -> (exists [b](not [(a b)]Q)) ] Check confluence by strongly closed criterion linear uniform BCPs: (0 on 0): { |- < (or <(not []P_1),(not []Q_1)>) <= (not <(and <[]P_1,[]Q_1>)>) => (or <(not []P_1),(not []Q_1)>) > } (1 on 1): { b#Q_1 |- < (exists [b](not [(a b)]Q_1)) <= (not <(forall [a][]Q_1)>) => (exists [b](not [(a b)]Q_1)) >, b#Q_1,c#Q_1 |- < (exists [b](not [(a b)]Q_1)) <= (not <(forall [a][]Q_1)>) => (exists [c](not [(a c)]Q_1)) >, a#Q_1 |- < (exists [b](not []Q_1)) <= (not <(forall [b][]Q_1)>) => (exists [a](not [(a b)]Q_1)) >, c#Q_1,a#Q_1 |- < (exists [b](not []Q_1)) <= (not <(forall [b][]Q_1)>) => (exists [c](not [(b c)]Q_1)) >, b#Q_1,a#Q_1 |- < (exists [b](not [(b a)(a c)]Q_1)) <= (not <(forall [c][]Q_1)>) => (exists [a](not [(a c)]Q_1)) >, b#Q_1,a#Q_1 |- < (exists [b](not [(b a)(a c)]Q_1)) <= (not <(forall [c][]Q_1)>) => (exists [b](not [(b c)]Q_1)) >, b#Q_1,a#Q_1,c#Q_1 |- < (exists [b](not [(b a)(a d)]Q_1)) <= (not <(forall [d][]Q_1)>) => (exists [c](not [(c d)]Q_1)) > } all BCPs are strongly closed result: YES time: 0 msec.